Starting on the Warmachine Forums I find this:
First, Let me introduce your Rules team for this forum. We call them the Infernals.MacallanLunatic CalmNot DicePoeticruseHaightMaudlinMootazThese fine soldiers of the shadow are here to answer your question and help you resolve any issues you have with the rules. Their words are official.
Next we go to a thread on combo strike and find the two posts that essentially end the discussion.
Read the last three or four posts.
The answer by Lazlo...
While no one I know that's played the game for a while has been confused by Combo Strike, I do know new players that have been. And it boils down to this...Combo Strike says, "Instead of making a normal damage roll, the POW of the damage roll is equal to this model's STR plus twice the POW of this weapon."On page 50 of Mk II Prime, under the MELEE WEAPONS section it says, "Melee Damage Roll = 2d6 + POW + STR"The problem is the overloading of the term POW. Going strictly by the rules, we get the following:POW of Combo Strike = POW of weapon x2 + STRSo the damage roll would be 2d6 + (POW of weapon x2 + STR) + STRCombo Strike should say something like the "P+S of the attack", rather than "POW of the damage roll". Or that the POW of the damage roll is equal to twice the POW of the weapon, and leave the STR part out (since it is already defined as being part of the melee damage roll).
Then the response by Lord Hedrahil...
Thanks Lazlo!!you understand my question...So...Instead of POW it, would sai P+S, is that correct?
Then Lazlo responds...
There might be a clearer wording, but essentially yes.All that's changing in the Combo Strike is that instead of getting multiple initial attacks you only get one, and you add the POW of the weapon twice instead of just once to the damage roll.So a STR 8 model with two POW 4 weapons and the Combo Strike special attack (* Attack) would have the options of:a) Two P+S 12 attacks, orb) One P+S 16 attack
And after all that, the MOD MACALLAN whose word is considered OFFICIAL says this...
I think that you are all on the same page.
To Sum up:
So it is Strength of model + POW x2 (each weapon) +2d6. That's all she wrote!
Hope that helps us for our next games!
here the problem, reread what he wrote (ive read this multipul times). here is quoted what he said:ReplyDelete
Going strictly by the rules, we get the following:POW of Combo Strike = POW of weapon x2 + STR So the damage roll would be 2d6 + (POW of weapon x2 + STR) + STR.
then he says: Combo Strike should say something like the "P+S of the attack", rather than "POW of the damage roll".
he is saying the wording is wrong, but that doesnt matter its what it says not what it should say. Untill privateer press addresses it. Thats like saying well the potms use to make a unit able to move when stunned so it still can they just forgot to rewrite that part.
mod macallan never says which one is right, the one that uses the rules or the made up versions.
Well the majority of the conversation near the end is all referring to the one version of the rules and that is when Mod Macallan chimes in.ReplyDelete
it is 2d6 + pow + pow + str one of the other infernals said it. its just really badly wordedReplyDelete